The Great Stock Buyback Illusion: Why Spending Billions on Your Own Shares Doesn't Automatically Make Shareholders Richer
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2026 | VALUE INVESTING & CAPITAL ALLOCATION Berkshire Hathaway spent $9.6 billion repurchasing shares in one quarter. But the real lesson isn't the size of the check. It's whether management understands the difference between a company's stock price and what the business is actually worth. Corporate America has developed a remarkable talent for making ordinary financial transactions sound like acts of generosity. A company announces that it's buying back $10 billion of its own stock, executives congratulate themselves for returning capital to shareholders, and investors applaud as though someone has just discovered an abandoned suitcase full of money. Sometimes the applause is deserved. Sometimes the company has merely spent an enormous amount of shareholder money buying something that was already overpriced. The press release looks equally impressive either way. This is what makes Berkshire Hathaway's recent repurchase activ...