You know, every now and then the market throws you a curveball. It’s not the kind of curveball you whiff at, but the kind that makes you pause, squint, and think, “Is this thing actually hittable—or is it going to break at the last second and send me tumbling?” That’s how I feel about Dynex Capital, ticker symbol DX. Sixteen percent. Monthly payouts. Sixteen percent! That’s not just a number; that’s a siren song for every income investor who’s been battered by rising rates and shrinking yields elsewhere.
But hold on. If you’ve been in this game long enough, you know there’s no such thing as free yield. Whenever you see a dividend that high, the market is basically screaming at you: “There’s risk here. Big, fat, ugly risk.” So the real question is: is Dynex’s 16% a gift, or a trap?
The Sweet Temptation of 16%
Let me set the scene: you’re an income-focused investor. You’ve got a portfolio sprinkled with your usual suspects—some dividend aristocrats like Coca-Cola, maybe a REIT or two like Realty Income, maybe even a high-yield ETF. You’re clipping coupons at 4, maybe 5, maybe 7% if you’ve got the stomach for it. And then Dynex walks in the room and says, “How about 16%? Oh, and by the way, I’ll pay you every month, like clockwork.”
That’s the temptation. Sixteen percent yield means that for every $10,000 you put in, you’re theoretically pocketing $1,600 a year. And because it’s monthly, you’re seeing that cash flow roll in every four weeks. For retirees, that’s like manna from heaven. For aggressive investors reinvesting dividends, it’s compounding on steroids.
But… here’s the thing. There’s always a “but.”
How Dynex Pulls This Off
Dynex isn’t your typical dividend darling. It’s a mortgage REIT. Let me translate that: Dynex doesn’t own shopping malls or apartment complexes. It owns paper. Specifically, mortgage-backed securities—both residential (think Fannie Mae stuff) and commercial (think loans bundled from office buildings or retail centers). Some of these are agency-backed, meaning the U.S. government guarantees the principal. Others are non-agency, meaning they’re a little riskier.
Now, mortgage REITs live and die by one thing: the spread. They borrow money short-term, they buy higher-yielding long-term mortgage securities, and they pocket the difference. Sounds simple, right? Except when interest rates start swinging like a wrecking ball. If your borrowing costs rise faster than your asset yields, your margins get squeezed. Dynex tries to hedge this risk, but hedging is like an umbrella in a hurricane—it only helps so much.
So, how do they pay a 16% dividend? Simple. They leverage up. They borrow heavily, buy more assets, and juice the income. Oh, and they occasionally issue new shares—diluting existing shareholders but keeping the dividend train rolling.
The Red Flags Nobody Should Ignore
Let me be brutally honest: Dynex’s payout ratio is absurd. It’s paying out way more than it earns. In fact, its payout ratio sits north of 280% based on earnings and over 500% based on cash flow. That’s like spending $5 for every $1 you make and saying, “Don’t worry, I’ll borrow the difference.” Eventually, the market starts asking questions.
And it’s not just the payout ratio. The company reported net losses in both Q2 and the first half of 2025. That’s right—losing money, while paying out 16%. You can’t do that forever without consequences. They’ve also filed a shelf registration, which is fancy financial-speak for “we’re going to sell more shares if we need cash.” Every new share sold means a smaller slice of the pie for existing shareholders.
Then there’s interest rates. If the Fed decides to hold higher for longer, borrowing costs stay elevated. If prepayment speeds on mortgages spike, the securities Dynex holds could lose value. It’s a delicate balance, and the margin for error is razor thin.
Why I’m Still Interested
And yet… here I am, still fascinated by this stock. Why? Because Dynex isn’t some fly-by-night operation. It’s been around for decades. It’s survived multiple rate cycles, multiple recessions, and the 2008 mortgage crisis—the ultimate stress test for any company in this space. That resilience counts for something.
Also, despite the losses, they’ve been aggressively raising capital—over half a billion dollars this year alone—and deploying it into agency MBS at attractive spreads. Their portfolio has grown by 44% year-to-date. That’s not the behavior of a company circling the drain; that’s a company trying to scale up, take advantage of dislocated markets, and maybe, just maybe, grow its way into covering that dividend.
The dividend itself has been creeping higher too—from $0.13 per month in 2024 to $0.17 now. That’s nearly 20% growth. Companies don’t raise dividends they think they’ll have to cut in six months. Either management is delusional, or they see something the market doesn’t.
The Risk/Reward Equation
Here’s where the rubber meets the road. Investing in Dynex is not about spreadsheets or payout ratios—it’s about risk tolerance. If you’re the kind of investor who lies awake at night because one of your stocks dropped 10%, Dynex is not for you. This is a stock that can swing like a pendulum. Its share price has been volatile, and any whiff of a dividend cut will send it tumbling.
But if you’re comfortable taking on risk in exchange for high monthly cash flow, Dynex has a place in your portfolio. Not your entire portfolio—God no—but maybe a slice. You hedge it with safer income names, you reinvest the dividends, and you accept that one day you might wake up to a dividend cut. If that happens, you pocket what you’ve earned up to that point and move on.
What I’ll Be Watching
For me, there are a few key things to watch:
-
Earnings vs. Dividends – Will they close the gap, or will losses continue?
-
ATM Issuance – How much dilution are we talking about here?
-
Interest Rate Trends – A stable or falling rate environment could be a tailwind.
-
Book Value Stability – Dynex’s ability to maintain or grow book value is crucial.
The Bottom Line
Dynex is like that friend who always shows up to the party with expensive champagne but never seems to have a job. You love having them around, but you’re always wondering where the money’s coming from. They’ve pulled it off so far, and maybe they’ll keep pulling it off. Maybe they’ll even grow. But you’d be a fool not to keep an eye on their wallet.
So, is Dynex’s 16% dividend a gift or a trap? Honestly, it’s both. It’s a gift if you understand the risks, size your position correctly, and ride the wave while it lasts. It’s a trap if you blindly chase the yield and assume it’s as safe as a Treasury bond.
For me, I’ll take a small sip of the champagne. I’ll enjoy the monthly payouts. But I’ll also keep my shoes by the door—because if things start to go south, I’m not going to be the last one out of the party.
Final Thought
Every investor has to answer this question for themselves: What’s your risk tolerance? If 16% sounds too good to be true, maybe it is. But if you can stomach the volatility, understand the business model, and keep a close watch on management’s moves, Dynex just might be one of those rare high-yield plays that rewards the bold.
So yes, I’m cautiously optimistic. I’ll take the yield, I’ll monitor the risks, and I’ll let Dynex prove whether this 16% is a flash in the pan—or the start of something remarkable.